Dothan Law Firm - A Division of Boles Holmes White, LLC

  • Home
  • About
  • Lawyers
    • Chris Richardson
    • William C. White
  • Practice Areas
    • Bankruptcy
    • Civil Lawsuits
    • Criminal Defense
    • Divorce and Family Law
    • DUI Defense
    • White Collar Defense & Investigations
    • Wills and Probate
  • Blog
  • Contact
+1 334 366 6086
  • Home
  • Criminal Law
  • The Ever Eroding 4th Amendment

The Ever Eroding 4th Amendment

Monday, 28 April 2014 / Published in Criminal Law, DUI

The Ever Eroding 4th Amendment

In an opinion released by the U.S. Supreme Court on April 22, 2014, the Court furthered the erosion of the 4th Amendment.  In Prado Navarette v. California, the Court essentially said that it’s “OK” to pull over a vehicle based upon an anonymous tip and little else.  The Petitioner was pulled over after an anonymous 911 caller stated that Petitioner ran her off the road five minutes earlier and gave an accurate description of the truck, which was found driving roughly in the area reported.  California Highway Patrol responded and followed the Petitioner’s vehicle for five minutes without any evidence of dangerous driving.

The Court stretched and stretched until it found the call was reliable, largely because it was a 911 call, based on a supposed eyewitness event.  The Court surmised that the 911 call was recorded and would prevent false reports, although absolutely nothing was gleaned about the caller other that she was female.  The Court then suggests that a vehicle running another off the road is an indication of drunk driving justifying a stop.

Only the minority lead by Justice Scalia got this one right.  The dissent asserts correctly that this ruling will allow law enforcement to pull over a vehicle simply based upon an anonymous caller asserting an uncorroborated instance of alleged bad driving if they can give a description and location of the suspect vehicle.  The majority ignores the fact that the call may be false or vindictive.  It’s simply an allegation coupled with information anyone on that highway could have given.

This is simply a scary holding as anyone in traffic that has an axe to grind with another driver can call in an anonymous tip and have them pulled over.  Even if the police know who the caller is, they may simply make a false allegation and the innocent driver will likely be the one having the consequence, police vs. driver or driver vs. driver.

  • Tweet

What you can read next

Police Make Arrest in Dothan Armed Robbery Case
Henry County Deputy Arrested
Alabama Drivers Paid to Participate in DUI Testing

Search

Categories

  • Alabama Law
  • Bankruptcy
  • Criminal Law
  • Divorce
  • Drug Crimes
  • DUI
  • Uncategorized

Recent Posts

  • What to do When There is a Warrant for Your Arrest

    Some people know when they have broken the law ...
  • Drug Distribution

    There is a debate within American society as to...
  • Can An Employer Use a Potential Employee’s Bankruptcy Against Him?

    Besides the social stigma of filing for bankrup...
  • Man Arrested for Theft of Electronic Walmart Shopping Cart

    Curtis Wymes, 25, has been arrested by Dothan p...
  • Headland Man Facing Felony Criminal Charges

    Kennon O’Bryan Hester, of Headland, has been ch...

Archives

The Dothan office of Boles Holmes White, LLC, represents clients throughout Southeast Alabama in wide range of legal matters.

OFFICE ADDRESS

661 West Main St
Dothan, AL 36301
USA

  • +1 334 366 6086
  • hello@dothanlawfirm.com

QUICK LINKS

  • Firm Overview
  • Video Center
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Disclaimer
  • Contact

SOCIALS

WEBSITE BY

© 2022 - 2023 By Boles Holmes White, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Website By AdToms.

TOP